Players Championship: Analyzing 4 most challenging holes at TPC Sawgrass

The Stadium Course at TPC Sawgrass in Ponte Vedra Beach, Florida, is most famous for two things: The Players Championship and its par-3 17th hole.

One could argue that this 137-yard par-3 is among the most famous short holes in the world, perhaps second only to the 12th hole at Augusta National.

But every golf fan knows about the 17th, and how water surrounds this island green.

Instead of exploring the nuances of the 17th hole, and a few others that give TPC Sawgrass its character, we decided to go in a different direction.

We analyzed the four most challenging holes from the 2024 Players Championship won by Scottie Scheffler. Whoever plays the best on this stretch of holes will likely have a good chance at victory come Sunday afternoon.

4. Hole 5 – Par 4, 469 Yards

Trouble looms all the way down the right-hand side of this beastly par-4.

A dogleg right, the fairway twists and turns like a snake, although it does feature a relatively generous landing area. That said, the ideal shot shape off the tee is a fade.

A lengthy sand trap and water lurk along the right while two other bunkers sit to the left of the fairway. Any pushed tee shot will find the trap, or if it goes even further right, it will find the penalty area. A 320-yard carry is required to clear this trouble.

Ask Keith Mitchell, who does not have the distance to make this carry, and frustratingly found the water on the 5th two seasons ago.

Yet, players should favor the right half of the fairway, as it provides a better angle.

The field will use long-to-mid irons for their second shots into a tricky green complex, which is well protected by waste bunkers, mounds, and palm trees.

The green primarily slopes from back to front, but it features a couple of run-offs, like on the back right.

Another run-off slopes towards the deep bunker that sits long and left and must be avoided.

Overall, in 2024, the 5th hole yielded 62 birdies while producing 67 bogies and 14 double bogies or worse. Whoever walks away with a four on this hole will leave satisfied.

3. Hole 8 – Par 3, 236 Yards

Photo by Chris Condon/PGA Tour

By far the most challenging par-3 at TPC Sawgrass, the 8th hole requires some players to hit a long iron while others will hit a fairway wood into a severely sloping, narrow green.

The length itself is a challenge, but so too are the nine bunkers scattered around the putting surface.

Two kidney-shaped traps sit at the front of the green, one left and one right. The green then slopes off of these two bunkers, funneling towards the middle of the green. Sometimes, players who hit their tee shots in that vicinity will see a lucky bounce, as their tee shots will carom off the slope and trickle towards the hole.

But most often, it will ricochet into the trap, leading to a tough up-and-down.

Alas, the 8th hole gave up only 53 birdies a year ago. It produced 93 bogies and seven doubles or worse, playing to an overall average score of 3.125, making it the third most challenging hole.

2. Hole 18 – Par 4, 462 Yards

Photo by Jennifer Perez/PGA Tour

You cannot go left on the par-4 18th, which explains why the finishing hole at TPC Sawgrass was the second most difficult in 2024.

It played 0.253 strokes above par and saw players make 92 bogies. Twenty-eight double bogies or worse were also recorded, primarily due to the large lake that this dogleg left wraps around.

The ideal shot shape off the tee is a draw, but players cannot over hook it for obvious reasons. But if a draw is not executed, and the tee shot misses right, trees, thick rough, spectator mounds, and a poor angle await. Perhaps no other tee shot in the world exemplifies Pete Dye’s brilliance such as this. Bailing right is not a good option, but so many players do so because of the water left.

Those trees to the right sit 281 yards off the tee, and plenty of players have held real estate there over the years. Anyone who has their tee shots end up there will face a difficult situation, often resulting in a bogey or worse.

Like the tee shot, the approach calls for accuracy too. You cannot go left, as the lake extends all the way to the putting surface.

A bunker also sits long and left of the green, which is an absolute no-go.

But bailing out right is not an option either.

From roughly 60 yards from the center of the green, mounds and a waste bunker sit short and right. Any player who pushes their tee shot into the trees will then have to deal with these ‘gumdrop’ shaped ridges in their view.

They only lead to awkward lies and frustration.

So, too, does this two-tiered green that primarily slopes from back-to-front. In doing so, the green also gently declines towards the water.

The 18th may be difficult, but it is a brilliant finishing hole.

1. Hole 14 – Par 4, 481 Yards

Photo by Chris Condon/PGA Tour

Players must find the fairway off the tee if they expect to walk away with at least a par on 14.

Gnarly rough and extensive mounds sit to the right of the fairway, while a long skinny sand trap runs down the entire length of the hole to the left. Water sits beyond the bunker and will absorb any tee shot pulled severely.

With that in mind, the landing area itself is reasonably wide.

Still, should players find the fairway off the tee, their second shot does not get any easier.

That same sand trap extends to the green, snatching any pulled approach. A tough up-and-in awaits anyone who finds it.

Five other pot bunkers and sand traps are scattered around this complex putting surface, which mostly slopes from right-to-left towards the Atlantic Ocean. It does feature numerous undulations and slopes, including one on the front right half of the green. Any shot short will funnel down into a collection area, which is also a tricky spot to make par from.

Last year, the 14th ranked as the most challenging hole at TPC Sawgrass, giving up only 33 birdies. Meanwhile, 99 bogies were made, the most of any hole, and that does not include the 22 double bogies or worse.

Jack Milko is a golf staff writer for SB Nation’s Playing Through. Follow him on X @jack_milko.