During the Teen Vogue Summit panel, Sophia revealed she doesn’t use black eyeliner but instead opts for dark gray in an effort to create a look that is “a little softer.” The star also shared that she no longer outlines her liner first and instead goes in with a pen marker right away, although she used to use eyeliner when perfecting her technique. While Sophia didn’t share which brands she uses (and we couldn’t find any clips online of her applying it either), we have rounded up three dark gray options that we think are great to recreate her look.

Urban Decay

24/7 Glide-On Waterproof Eyeliner Pencil in Smoke

Kiko Milano

Super Color Waterproof Eyeliner in 10 Pearly Charcoal

Manon’s eyeliner

Michael Buckner/Getty Images

Manon has gone viral for her straight eyebrows, inspiring more than one fellow member to follow in her footsteps, but her eyeliner is also not to be slept on. The star favors a more subtle eyeliner look, so if you are just introducing it into your look, it’s the perfect place to start. The focus of Manon’s eye look is on her long eyelashes, so a good lengthening mascara, extensions, falsies, or even a lash lift are a good place to start. As seen on her Glossier tutorial, Manon actually uses the brand’s Brow Flick in brown to create a super subtle cat flick only on the outer corners of her eyes.

Glossier

Brow Flick in Brown

Daniela’s eyeliner

Phillip Faraone/Getty Images