Fantasy reboots have a reputation for missing the mark. Whether they rush through beloved material or dilute what made the original special, second attempts often struggle to justify their existence. Yet every so often, a redo does not just correct past mistakes, it defines the story for an entire generation.

That’s exactly what happened with Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood. Premiering in 2009, this ambitious reimagining of Hiromu Arakawa’s manga delivered a sweeping steampunk epic that balanced political intrigue, emotional devastation, and explosive action. More than a remake, it became the definitive version of the story.

Brotherhood is a Faithful Retelling That Elevates the Source

Unlike its 2003 predecessor, which diverged significantly from the manga, Brotherhood commits fully to Arakawa’s original narrative. The result is a tightly structured story that escalates with purpose. Early episodes move briskly, assuming familiarity, but the pacing soon settles into a confident rhythm that rewards patience.

At its core are brothers Edward and Alphonse Elric, whose forbidden alchemical ritual costs them dearly. Their quest to restore their bodies unfolds across a militarized nation hiding dark secrets. The show’s steampunk aesthetic, full of automail prosthetics, industrial cities, and arcane science, gives the emotional journey a tactile, lived-in weight.

What truly makes the adaptation near-perfect is its long-game storytelling. Seemingly minor characters resurface with devastating importance. Political conspiracies intertwine with metaphysical horror. By the time the story reaches its final arc, every thread feels intentional, converging in a climax that is both grand in scale and deeply personal.

Brotherhood’s action sequences remain some of anime’s most exhilarating. Alchemy-based combat turns battles into strategic chess matches, where understanding equivalent exchange can mean survival. Each homunculus encounter introduces new visual flair and thematic depth, ensuring fights are never empty action or meaningless filler.

Yet the series is equally invested in big ideas. Questions about faith, sacrifice, imperialism, and scientific ambition run throughout its 64-episode run. The Amestrian military’s moral compromises mirror real-world anxieties, grounding the fantasy in sobering reality. Few genre series manage to explore ethics without sacrificing momentum.

What ultimately makes Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood near-perfect, though, is its emotional sincerity. Humor breaks tension without undermining tragedy. Supporting characters, from loyal soldiers like Maes Hughes to conflicted antagonists like Scar, feel fully realized. When the finale arrives, it offers not just resolution, but catharsis earned through careful buildup and genuine growth.

More than a successful reboot, Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood stands as proof that revisiting a story can amplify its power when handled with clarity and respect. In a genre crowded with uneven retellings, it remains a rare example of lightning striking twice, and somehow burning even brighter the second time.

• 

  Maxey Whitehead

  Alphonse Elric

• 

  Vic Mignogna

  Edward Elric