Best Multi-Sport Gym Tote: Arc’teryx Carrier 45 Gear Tote, $180

At a glance, this open-top tote is a simple oversized gear bag with handles. That’s not wrong, but you already know what we’re going to tell you: there’s more. Inside, fold-away dividers built into the bag’s lining create compartments large enough for separating shoes from clothes, or containing your climbing kit on one side and your lifting duds on the other. If you don’t mind the lack of a zippered top, it’s the ideal setup if your gym’s amenities include more than weight racks and treadmills. The handles are long enough to throw it over your shoulder, so overpacking isn’t an issue. And, lastly, the one easily doubles and triples as a beach bag, camping bag, and more.

Best Lightweight Gym Bag: Bellroy Lite Duffel

You know a bag’s going to be light when the word is right there in the name (without the excess “g” and “h” too). The Lite Duffel weighs in around 21 ounces, but punches above its class when it comes to features. Those include an exterior organizational pocket, a detachable shoulder strap, and a big main compartment that’s extra-accessible from an extended zipper and has additional interior pockets as well (one is designed specifically for an AirTag for keeping track of your tube socks).

What to Look for in a Gym Bag

Materials: These days, most gym bags are made from some form of nylon, but some of our favorites incorporate leather and canvas, too. Nylon is easiest to clean and resists odors better than other materials, but if you’re looking for something that’s going to last, make sure you figure out how thick the material is. For example, some cheaper nylon bags may end up being quite flimsy, while other bags, like the Peak Design bag we mentioned, is made from bulletproof 600D nylon that could probably be dragged behind a car without busting. Make sure you also consider the zippers—nothing is worse than a faulty zipper that stops working after a few uses.

Type of Bag: Yes, this story is specifically geared toward gym bags, but as you may have noticed, many of the bags on our list are intended for travel, weekends away, or commuting. Any bag can be a gym bag if you want it to be! Don’t worry so much about the name of the bag or what the brand states as the bag’s main purpose, just make sure it has what you want. Sometimes that’s a shoe compartment, sometimes that means finding a bag that can be carried by hand or slung over your shoulder, and sometimes you just want something cheap to tote a towel and fresh pair of boxers. In the end, this is up to you, so read the details, look at the images, and if you decide you like a bag, make it your go-to.

Size: There’s no reason to drag a bag the size of your checked suitcase to the gym. If you’re only bringing a change of clothes and a pair of shoes, you’ll want a bag that’s just big enough to carry all of that because your workout shouldn’t be the commute to the gym itself. Also, take into consideration the size of your gym’s lockers—if you get a bag too big, you’ll have to leave your gear out in the open, just asking to be stolen.

Gym Bag FAQ

How We Tested

Not only is our team here at GQ obsessed with bags, but we’re also a pretty sporty bunch. We are just as dedicated to spending time at the Park Slope YMCA or LES Equinox as we are to keeping our finger on the pulse of the latest style trends. This means that we definitely use the things we talk about. So we test bags constantly, hauling our workout gear all over the place, looking for the best of the best to then recommend our favorites to you. Our group of editors and writers includes marathon runners, road cyclists, rec league soccer players, self-described meatheads, and Barry’s die-hards—so you can be sure that each bag we recommend has been put through its paces.