Some fictional bands feel so real that it is easy to forget they never actually existed. Whether they were created for a comedy, a musical, or a mockumentary, these groups produced unforgettable songs, memorable performances, and devoted fan bases that continue long after the credits roll. In many cases, audiences still stream their music, buy the merchandise, and wish they could attend a concert that will never happen. Reddit users had plenty of favorites, and it is easy to understand why. These are fifteen fake movie and television bands that people still wish had been real enough to headline a world tour.

Spinal Tap – This Is Spinal Tap (1984)

The ultimate fictional rock band, Spinal Tap became so convincing that many people initially thought the mockumentary was a real documentary.

The Blues Brothers – The Blues Brothers (1980)

Jake and Elwood’s band became so popular that it crossed into the real world with hit albums and live performances.

Stillwater – Almost Famous (2000)

Cameron Crowe created a classic seventies rock band that felt authentic enough to have shared stages with real legends.