As mentioned earlier, the trick with Black Honey is that it looks a little different on everyone, depending on skin tone. That means, while there’s no match that will look the same on everyone, there’s probably at least one shade out there for each person that could get very close.

Case in point: This high-shine Revlon balm has several people in the reviews claiming that various different shades remind them of Black Honey. These range from Glazed Mauve, a more muted purplish berry, to the pinker Nude Illuminator, the darker, cooler Black Cherry and even Revlon’s own iconic shade, Rum Raisin. All this to say, there’s almost definitely something out there for you — it may just require knowing your undertones first.

As for the formula, it’s more like a gloss-balm hybrid than a lipstick-balm hybrid. It delivers on shine and moisture, containing hyaluronic acid and aloe for a buttery, smoothing feel that isn’t sticky like a regular gloss.

Get it from Amazon for $8.97+.