Few recent TV adaptations have sparked as much debate as The Lord of the Rings: The Rings of Power, and not always for the right reasons. While the series undeniably captures the vast scale of Middle-earth, it often feels disconnected from what made The Lord of the Rings so enduring. Beneath the blockbuster visuals and cinematic polish lies a fundamental misunderstanding of Tolkien’s core themes.

What could have been a spiritual successor to The Lord of the Rings (both the books and movies) instead became a divisive attempt to chase the prestige fantasy wave popularized by Game of Thrones. In prioritizing complexity and grit, it loses the emotional clarity that defined Tolkien’s work and Peter Jackson’s cinematic adaptation of his stories. Fortunately, the live-action One Piece has stepped in as an unexpected alternative.

Against all odds, the two seasons of Netflix’s One Piece have quietly emerged as the spiritual successor to LotR that Amazon’s The Rings of Power never became. By embracing themes of hope, friendship, and moral conviction, it captures the essence of what’s made Tolkien’s world resonate across generations.

Netflix’s One Piece Is The Spiritual LOTR Successor That Rings Of Power Should Have Been

Despite drawing directly from J.R.R Tolkien’s extensive history of Middle-earth, Amazon’s The Rings of Power doesn’t feel like a true continuation of his storytelling spirit. From the original Lord of the Rings trilogy to the Hobbit, Tolkein’s tales all thrive on the idea that even the smallest acts of courage can shape the fate of the world. Hope is not just present in his work, it is the thematic foundation of them.

In contrast, The Rings of Power often leans into ambiguity and moral grayness. Characters like Galadriel (Morfydd Clark) are portrayed with a harsher, more conflicted edge, which distances them from Tolkien’s more idealistic vision. Netflix’s One Piece, on the other hand, takes the opposite approach. Monkey D. Luffy (Iñaki Godoy) is unwavering in his belief in freedom, loyalty, and doing what is right. His journey is not about internal darkness but about spreading light.

This clarity of purpose mirrors Frodo Baggins’ (Elijah Wood) determination in The Lord of the Rings far more than any character arcs in The Rings of Power. Even supporting One Piece characters reinforce this Tolkienesque tone. Roronoa Zoro (Mackenyu) and Nami (Emily Rudd) are layered, but their arcs ultimately point toward trust and unity rather than cynicism. The series consistently emphasizes that people can change and choose good.

Where The Rings of Power often feels influenced by Game of Thrones-style grittiness and murky morality, One Piece embraces sincerity. Its heroes are heroes, its villains are villains, and the importance of fighting against evil and injustice is clear-cut. In taking this approach, One Piece captures something The Rings of Power struggles to maintain: the belief that goodness, no matter how challenged, will endure. That belief is the beating heart of Tolkien’s work, and it’s alive and well in every episode of One Piece.

The One Piece Manga Is The Definitive Fantasy Epic Of Our Times

The live-action One Piece being a spiritual successor to The Lord of the Rings is far less surprising when looking at the source material. While its world of pirates and Devil Fruits couldn’t be more different from Middle-earth, Eiichiro Oda’s One Piece manga occupies a similar cultural space. Like Tolkien’s saga, it is a sprawling epic defined by its themes rather than just its plot.

At its core, One Piece is about the strength of the human spirit. Luffy’s journey isn’t just about becoming Pirate King, it’s about challenging oppression and inspiring others to pursue freedom. This mirrors the thematic backbone of The Lord of the Rings, where resisting domination is central. The live-action One Piece succeeds both as an adaptation of the source material and a successor to LotR because it understands this foundation. That’s why the Straw Hat crew’s moments of triumph feel just as uplifting as any of Frodo’s. They are equally rooted in genuine moral conviction.

J.R.R. Tolkien’s work has always been about the quiet power of goodness overcoming overwhelming darkness. One Piece, both the manga and live-action version, embraces that same philosophy. This is also where The Rings of Power falters. Despite having access to one of the richest fantasy mythologies ever created, it often prioritizes spectacle and intrigue over thematic resonance. The result is a series that looks like Middle-earth but doesn’t always feel like it.

One Piece, by contrast, proves that honoring the spirit of a story matters more than replicating its surface details. Its success highlights a simple truth: respecting source means understanding why a story matters. In capturing that essence, Netflix’s One Piece has captured the true spirit of a modern fantasy epic that carries forward the legacy J.R.R. Tolkien began.

Release Date

August 31, 2023

Network

Netflix

Showrunner

Matt Owens, Steven Maeda, Joe Tracz

Directors

Tim Southam, Marc Jobst, Josef Kubota Wladyka

Writers

Tiffany Greshler, Diego Gutierrez, Allison Weintraub, Lindsay Gelfand

• 

  Iñaki Godoy

  Monkey D. Luffy

•